Pictures: Museum of the Holy Shrine of Imam Hussein How Iraqi people became the best hosts in history? - Part II How Iraqi people became the best hosts in history - Part I The center holds a seminar On the unseen dimensions of the personality of Imam Hussein, peace be upon him (Part One) Mr. Abdul Amir Al-Quraishi receives the delegation of the Iranian Arbaeen Committee From the sea to Al-Hussein sacred slaughter place Roofing the streets of the old city (views) A delegation from Karbala Center for Studies and Research visits the Media Department at Al-Hussaini Holy Shrine Karbala: Tarateel Sajjadiyya Festival With Pictures … Arbaeen pilgrims walking from the southernmost point of Iraq Publication of the eleventh issue of (The Week) newsletter Karbala theater produced by history and represented by reality (scenes) The committees of the International Conference for the Arbaeen visitation hold their session in preparation for the conference A meeting on ideological linguistic vocabulary The incident of Karbala Ashura: History & Philosophy Tell me about Ashura The dark night of loneliness ( the Night of Wahsha) is a witness to the tragedy of Karbala..and only candles illuminate the night of loneliness ?Ashura is the largest annual pilgrimage in the world. So what does it commemorate Rituals Immortalized Imam Hussein’s Battle of Karbala
KCSR'S Projects / Arbaeen Pilgrimage / Arbaeen Encyclopedia
11:29 AM | 2020-08-24 1059
جانب من تشيع الشهيد زكي غنام
تحميل الصورة

Evaluation and Criticism of the Opposing Views against Ziyāra -Part I-

Despite the consensus of Islamic sects regarding permissibility of ziyāra in general and permissibility of ziyāra of the holy Prophet (PBUH&HP) in particular, a few of the followers of the Hanbali sect announced ziyāra as against monotheism and invalid. The first person who ordained prohibition of ziyāra was Barbahari, a Hanbali scholar of 4 th century.

After him, ibn Taymiyah and then his student ibn Qayyim, both of Hanbali scholars in 7 th and 8 th centuries, opposed ziyāra. Later, beliefs of ibn Taymiyah formed the foundations of the Wahhabi beliefs and they too opposed ziyāra of graves and began destroying the graves.

Opinion of this group is that ziyāra of graves is a kind of polytheism and also an heretical innovation. However, ziyāra would be polytheism if it was not permitted by Islamic law and if the person doing the ziyāra was doing it with the intention of worshipping the visited. While as explained, permissibility and legitimacy of ziyāra is quite clear and thus it can not be regarded as a polytheistic act. In addition, the goal of ziyāra is to honor and commemorate the deceased. There is no issue of worship so that one might regard it as a polytheistic action. It might be argued that ziyāra of any grave other than the Prophet’s as a religious act is an innovation. But we can deduce from the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah in regard to going to ziyāra of certain graves the permissibility and favorability of this act, and this favorability and permissibility can be generalized to other graves too. From the viewpoint of Sunni scholars generalization of good deeds even with title of religiously legal is not unfavorable rather it is considered as good innovation and so it is favorable and desirable. Based on this, in accordance to the Sunnis, ziyāra of graves is regarded as a good innovation and is permissible. The Shi’ah viewpoint too is that ziyāra is Sunnah, not innovation.

The Wahhabis forbid Muslims from visiting graves relying on a narration that says the Messenger of God implored Allah to withhold His Mercy from some Jews and Christians because they made the graves of their Prophets as worshipping places. In response, it has been said that the Islamic purpose of building masjids besides graves of great religious figures is that the pilgrims of graves may perform their obligatory duties and acts there before or after their ziyāra.

In addition, with due attention to the Verse 21 of Surah Kahf it becomes clear that building masjids besides graves is not a sign of polytheism; for, when the story of the companions of the Kahf was divulged monotheism was prevailing.

Opposers of ziyāra also cite a narration about Imam Sajjad seeing a person next to the grave of the Messenger of God and forbidding him to do that, reminding him a hadith from the Prophet (PBUH&HP) in that regard.

However, the context of this prohibition shows that this report was about someone who was visiting the grave of the Prophet (PBUH&HP) to excess and was disregarding his other duties. The intent of this prohibition, therefore, was not repudiation of ziyāra itself.



Pilgrimage “Ziyāra” from the Viewpoint of the Holy Quran, Hadiths and Theological Discourses-An Entry from Encyclopaedia of the World Islam [p 16-18].

Author: Maryam Kiani Farid

Translated by Mojganeh Saffarnia.



Facebook Facebook Twitter Messenger Messenger WhatsApp Telegram Viber Email
Related topics
2020-10-17 1641